• Anna Huschka

Understanding the Supreme Court's Decision to Turn Down the Trans Mountain Pipeline Appeal

Updated: May 31

In order to properly understand the context of an appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, we need to go back to May 2019 when a limit on heavy oil flow was proposed by the provincial government of British Columbia (1). The British Columbia Court of Appeal unanimously decided that this proposal crossed over into the federal jurisdiction, since the Trans Mountain Pipeline expansion transverses multiple provinces (1). The proposal would have been problematic if passed, as interprovincial projects are a sole power dictated to the Federal Government in section 92 of the Constitution (2). Secondly, passing of the proposal would have resulted in difficulty for the National Energy Board to work on current and future projects, also contributing to why this request was denied (1). If you’re interested in reading more about the distribution of powers of each level of government, you can click here to read a report from the British Columbia Court of Appeal.


There is a hierarchy to our judiciary system, in which a case starts at the lowest municipal court, with the ability to appeal to higher provincial and federal courts as deemed necessary. In this case, since the provincial government of British Columbia was fighting the pipeline, the case started out in provincial court and was appealed upwards to the federal Supreme Court (2). The Supreme Court came to a unanimous conclusion to dismiss B.C.’s appeal of a lower court, allowing for the B.C. Court of Appeal decision to stand. This decision ended B.C.’s legal fight against the expansion of the Trans Mountain Pipeline (2).


The plan for the $7.4 billion Trans Mountain Pipeline expansion will increase the barrels of oil moved per day from 300,000 to approximately 890,000 (4). There has been a polarized reaction amongst the provinces to the Trans Mountain Pipeline Expansion. Following the Supreme Court’s refusal to try the case, B.C. Premier John Horgan vowed to use his provincial power to protect any ecosystems or communities that would be at risk due to completion and use of the pipeline (2). Premier of Alberta, Jason Kenney, was very pleased with the decision made by the Supreme Court, declaring it as a success for Alberta, as the project is supposed to help reduce oil prices, as well as grant access to Alberta oil for international markets (2). This move is expected to increase oil revenue by $3.7 billion per year (4).


In terms of the completion of the pipeline, since the project has already undergone assessments by both the National Energy Board and the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency, and has twice been approved by the Federal Government, it is expected for the project to move forward and construction to begin (2).

Resources:


1. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/trans-mountain-bc-appeal-court-government-response-1.5148568


2. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/supreme-court-bc-reference-trans-mountain-1.5429423


3. https://www.bccourts.ca/jdb-txt/ca/19/01/2019BCCA0181.htm


4. https://www.transmountain.com/project-overview

21 views

About Us

Shake Up The Establishment is a youth-led, registered (#1190975-4) national non-partisan non-profit organization that operates within the geographical confines of what is currently known as "Canada", but what is referred to by its First Peoples, as Turtle Island. Indigenous peoples have inhabited Turtle Island for over 10,000 years, and were the sole inhabitants less than 500 years ago. We acknowledge that our address resides on Treaty 3 land, and is the traditional territory of the Erie, Neutral, Huron-Wendat, Haudenosaunee and Mississaugas Peoples. Turtle Island is still home to many Indigenous peoples and we at SUTE are thankful to be able to live, learn and work on this territory, whilst continuing to create meaningful change for the climate justice movement. We are aware that our actions as an organization and the work we put out have an impact on our land, and on all that inhabit it. We are humbled to be able to follow the lead of centuries long Indigenous-led efforts towards the protection and stewardship of this land and the people that inhabit it. We are committed to continually evaluating & decolonizing our practices, and we do our best to incorporate the lived experiences of the land defenders and protectors within our work. We also want to honour the voices of Black, and non-Black people of colour within our work, and continually recognize their resiliency in the face of years of systemic oppression as imposed by the Canadian state.

 

Our enterprise is inclusive of all folx who call the geographical confines of what is currently known as Canada, home, and we celebrate the horizontal learning that comes from our diverse identities. As an organization, we will try our utmost best to ensure that only individuals with lived experiences are speaking on behalf of their communities, while still recognizing that Black, Indigenous and communities of colour as well as the LGBTQ2S+ community, are not a monolith. We firmly believe in accountability, and commit to being as transparent as possible in our activism space; to research our topics well, support and centre community care, and minimize any harm, no matter the intent. We have strict policies and procedures to uphold these tenets, and update these on a yearly (or as-needed) basis.

106-325 Winterberry Drive, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada L8J 0B6

© 2020 Shake Up The Establishment

Stay Caught Up!

Sign up to receive our monthly newsletter for major political updates, our latest educational resources, events and more!