An Introduction To Pipelines In Canada

Updated: Sep 22, 2019

Pipelines are often the centrepiece of climate action debates because they are an important piece of fossil fuel infrastructure and a risk to surrounding environments and communities (1,11). Recently, the Trans Mountain Expansion (TMX) pipeline project has been in the spotlight due to legal battles spearheaded predominantly by Indigenous communities and environmental organizations in Canada. The debates surrounding these projects are often quite polarizing, so the goal of this piece is to dissect common arguments from both sides of the pipeline debate. Supporters of pipeline projects often cite the fact that without the availability of pipelines to transport the crude oil manufactured in Canada, companies will likely rely on transport by rail to keep up with crude oil production (3). This raises safety concerns due to the poor accident record of crude oil rail transport in the past (e.g. the Lac-Mégantic disaster of 2013) (3, 10). This, combined with potential economic advantages of increased crude oil production and export provided by new pipelines, is an attractive case for increasing the use of pipelines throughout Canada (3). It is important to note that in response to the safety concerns of crude oil rail transport, the rail cars used in disasters, such as the one in Lac-Mégantic are, are being phased out in favor of safer, more advanced rail cars (1).


Opponents of pipelines argue that the construction of dedicated oil transport infrastructure to countries outside of Canada’s borders is counterproductive to energy and climate goals set out by the Canadian government (1). Moreover, they argue that spills from pipelines, regardless of being less frequent than rail transport, have a much higher potential to be catastrophic to the surrounding environments and fresh water supply if not immediately discovered (1). This concern stems from high-profile pipeline oil spills such as the one in 2012 in Red Deer River, Alberta, where almost 500,000 liters of crude oil leaked into the Red Deer River (12). Plains Midstream, the owner of said pipeline, was charged with 2 counts of violating environmental laws and fined $1.3 million (12). Despite being detrimental to the environment and local communities, articles such as “A Comparison of the Risk of Transporting Crude Oil: Rail vs. Pipeline,” published by the International Association for Energy Economics (IAEE) energy forum, report that the volume of oil leaked per spill was on average much less with pipelines than with rail transport, and that companies are able to transport a significantly higher volume of oil by pipeline (5). Furthermore, the lack of oversight that has led to past pipeline spills is largely attributable to Canadian regulatory organizations such as the National Energy Board (NEB) (1). At present, the NEB is responsible for the regulation of around 73,000 km of pipelines in Canada (13). The NEB have also been at the center of legal battles over the TMX pipeline, which was recently approved for expansion (14). The government of Canada is currently working on updating/replacing the NEB with the Canadian Energy Regulator (CER) (13). As we move into a new age of energy production, it is important to ensure that Canada’s investments are not only true to our values, but that they continue to be effective with the coming shifts towards renewable energy production. Many of the major Canadian parties are promising both short- and long-term goals for our fossil fuel economy (7,8,9). Some parties are committing to using only domestically-produced oil and gas, and others to ending fossil fuel subsidies (7,8,9).


Overall, most parties are committing, broadly, to reduce and eventually eliminate the production of greenhouse gases in the oil and gas industry (7,8,9). How this country moves forward with the construction of energy infrastructure (e.g. pipelines) must match up with these goals in an environmentally sound way, considering all of the communities potentially impacted by the project.


(More information about changes to the CER regulatory body can be found here).



76 views

About Us

Shake Up The Establishment is a youth-led, registered (#1190975-4) national non-partisan non-profit organization that operates within the geographical confines of what is currently known as "Canada", but what is referred to by its First Peoples, as Turtle Island. Indigenous peoples have inhabited Turtle Island for over 10,000 years, and were the sole inhabitants less than 500 years ago. We acknowledge that our address resides on Treaty 3 land, and is the traditional territory of the Erie, Neutral, Huron-Wendat, Haudenosaunee and Mississaugas Peoples. Turtle Island is still home to many Indigenous peoples and we at SUTE are thankful to be able to live, learn and work on this territory, whilst continuing to create meaningful change for the climate justice movement. We are aware that our actions as an organization and the work we put out have an impact on our land, and on all that inhabit it. We are humbled to be able to follow the lead of centuries long Indigenous-led efforts towards the protection and stewardship of this land and the people that inhabit it. We are committed to continually evaluating & decolonizing our practices, and we do our best to incorporate the lived experiences of the land defenders and protectors within our work. We also want to honour the voices of Black, and non-Black people of colour within our work, and continually recognize their resiliency in the face of years of systemic oppression as imposed by the Canadian state.

 

Our enterprise is inclusive of all folx who call the geographical confines of what is currently known as Canada, home, and we celebrate the horizontal learning that comes from our diverse identities. As an organization, we will try our utmost best to ensure that only individuals with lived experiences are speaking on behalf of their communities, while still recognizing that Black, Indigenous and communities of colour as well as the LGBTQ2S+ community, are not a monolith. We firmly believe in accountability, and commit to being as transparent as possible in our activism space; to research our topics well, support and centre community care, and minimize any harm, no matter the intent. We have strict policies and procedures to uphold these tenets, and update these on a yearly (or as-needed) basis.

106-325 Winterberry Drive, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada L8J 0B6

© 2020 Shake Up The Establishment

Stay Caught Up!

Sign up to receive our monthly newsletter for major political updates, our latest educational resources, events and more!